Sunday, December 19, 2010
Paying for Tax Cuts: Whose Money is it?
by Ron Paul
George Orwell warned us about the use of meaningless words in politics -- words that are endlessly repeated by sloganeering politicians until they have no meaning at all. Meaningless words certainly were on display last week during congressional debate over the latest tax bill. Over and over again we heard trite, empty phrases like "tax cuts for the wealthiest 2%", "tax giveaways", "tax earmarks", and "borrowing money to give to millionaires." Time and time again the same falsehoods were presented as fact and reported as such by our credulous media.
But all of these cliches about taxes are based on the presumption that government has a right to all your income, so government gives you something when it allows you to keep a portion of that income. To this mindset, tax cuts represent a cost to government. It's argued that money that really ought to go to the most noble of purposes, wealth redistribution via taxation, is being kept by greedy people and corporations who just don't want to pay their fair share.
Far too many Americans truly believe that tax cuts represent a government giveaway, indistinguishable from an outright subsidy or entitlement payment. To combat this mindset we need to be clear with our language. A subsidy, properly understood, occurs when government takes tax dollars and gives them to favored individuals, companies or industry. A tax cut by contrast simply means government takes less from an individual, company or industry. When government takes less from you, it has not given you anything. It merely has harmed you less. This is the critical distinction that has been lost in the endless tired debate about tax policy.
Of course, the bill passed last week did contain some actual spending, mostly in the form of an extension of unemployment benefits for another 13 months. The total spending in the bill amounted to about $60 billion, but the tax savings in the bill, meaning the amount of money that will remain in the hands of the taxpayers rather than being sent to Washington is approximately $850 billion. So while a clean tax bill would have certainly been preferable, the tax relief it contains is significant. It means $850 billion will be spent, saved or invested by American citizens rather than being sent into the black hole known as the federal treasury.
The media however dutifully reported that opposition to the bill came from concerned members of Congress who felt the $850 billion "cost" of the bill was too high and would add too much to the deficit. As always, they could not distinguish between government giving and government taking away. The American people already pay plenty in federal taxes. The deficit is the result of a spending problem, not a revenue problem. Had the bill not passed, millions of Americans would have seen their paychecks shrink in January due to the increased tax withholding. That is the plain and simple truth, and that is why I voted for the bill.
Ron Paul is America's leading voice for limited, constitutional government, low taxes, free markets, a return to sound monetary policies, and a sensible foreign policy that puts America first.
Ron Paul is Leading in Iowa so CNN is trying to bring down Ron Paul , How predictable and cowardly is the mainstream media. They tried this...
November 17, 2010 C-SPAN Ron Paul "It's Time To Shrug Off The Shackles Of This Government!
Now THAT is journalism. Can you even imagine if our 'mainstream' media cared about facts and getting to the bottom of things like t...
We are living in an insane TIME, but there is one Voice that is pulling us back from the brink that that man is RON PAUL! , If it wasnt for...
Ron Paul criticized the U.S. government's efforts to shut down WikiLeaks and attack Julian Assange, and compared the murderous conseque...
Ron Paul On Rick Perry Dropping Out Of The Presidential Race ...Thank God an Good Riddance! We don't need forced inoculations and priv...
Ron Paul was barely given any time to speak in the last debate .Just imagine what it will be like when only Ron Paul and Romney are left I...
February 11, 2011 C-SPAN "Foreign aid is taking money from the poor people of a rich country and giving it to the rich people of a p...
Ron Paul won a Stunning Second Place Victory in New Hampshire! Ron Paul speaks from the heart unlike all these puppet canidates that read ...
Ron Paul : Greece Riots Could come to America Congressman and Presidential Candidate Dr. Ron Paul says the violence rocking Greece threate...